Wooden vs Plastic Toilet Seats

Bathroom Scape may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page. This comes at no additional cost to you, and all the prices and availability are accurate at the time of publishing.

Selecting the perfect toilet seat for your bathroom renovation can be an individual preference, but it is imperative to assess both wood and plastic options before settling on one. Learn which is superior between wooden vs plastic toilet seats.

Choosing between various types of toilet seats may seem daunting at first, yet understanding their benefits and drawbacks will help you find one that complements your house and way of life. Weigh all pros and cons carefully to make a sound decision.

This article will highlight the distinctions between wood and plastic toilet seats, from material dissimilarities to hygiene and upkeep considerations. After reading, you should understand which option is the most suitable for your goals.

Wooden Vs. Plastic Toilet Seats – Pros and Cons

Wooden Toilet Seats

Comfort Seats C3B2R220BN Toilet Seat, Round, Rattan Bamboo


  • Unquestionably stylish and timeless. Wooden toilet seats can add a touch of traditional beauty to any bathroom.
  • Very comfortable since wood absorbs temperature quickly and evenly.
  • Easy to customize with paint or varnish if desired.


  • More expensive than plastic alternatives.
  • Harder to clean and maintain. Wood is more susceptible to warping, staining, and water damage.
  • They require frequent oiling, polishing, and regular cleaning to keep the wood in good condition.

Plastic Toilet Seats

BEMIS 70 000 Toilet Seat, ROUND, Plastic, White


  • Cheaper than wooden counterparts.
  • Much easier to clean and maintain since plastic is more durable and less prone to staining and warping.
  • Easy to customize with paint or vinyl stickers.


  • Not as comfortable since plastic can become very cold or hot depending on the temperature.
  • It can become brittle over time, leading to cracks and other damage.
  • Not as stylish or timeless as wooden toilet seats.

Wooden vs Plastic Toilet Seats – Which is Better?

MAYFAIR 880SLOW 000 Caswell Toilet Seat will Slowly Close and Never Loosen, ROUND, Long Lasting Plastic, White


If comfort is your top concern, wooden toilet seats are the obvious choice. The warmth and padding of wood give you an incomparable level of coziness compared to plastic surfaces.

Not only that, but ergonomic contours provide extra cushioning exactly where it’s most needed making them an excellent choice for those seeking maximum pleasure in their restroom experience.

Winner: Wood


When it comes to deciding between wooden and plastic toilet seats, the price may be the determining factor. Wooden seating typically costs more than plastic, depending on the type of wood used and its construction quality. Naturally, plastic tends to provide a better value for your money due to lower costs and less upkeep than wooden toilets.

Winner: Tie


Plastic toilet seats trump wooden ones in terms of both cost and longevity. Not only are they more affordable, but some can last up to 10 years or longer! Wooden toilet seats may be pricier yet have a shorter life expectancy due to their delicate composition.

The lifespan will depend on the type of wood used and how it is cared for. However, plastic usually surpasses its wooden counterpart when it comes to durability.

Winner: Plastic


Sanitation is an essential element to consider when contrasting wooden and plastic toilet seats. Toilet covers are some of the most germ-ridden items in your residence, consequently mandating regular cleaning.

Wooden surfaces require more maintenance than plastic surfaces, which makes them more susceptible to bacteria and other contaminants. Plastic toilet seats, on the other hand, are much easier to clean and maintain since they don’t need frequent polishing and oiling.

Winner: Plastic


In terms of aesthetic appeal, wooden toilet seats are the clear winner. They possess natural beauty and timeless elegance, and their warmth and inviting atmosphere can instantly transform any bathroom from dull to luxurious. Many come with various finishes and colors, including natural wood, stained, and painted options.

However, plastic toilet seats are often more affordable and can come in various colors and styles. Both materials can provide a modern, sleek look to your bathroom, so it’s essential to consider your personal preference when choosing a toilet seat.

Winner: Wood

Other factors to consider

Other factors to consider when deciding between wooden and plastic toilet seats include durability, cost, and maintenance. Wooden toilet seats are often more durable and can last for years, while plastic seats can become scratched or cracked more easily.

Wooden seats also tend to be more expensive than plastic and require more maintenance, as they may need to be refinished or repainted. Plastic toilet seats should be your go-to choice if you’re looking for affordability and minimal upkeep. However, they won’t last as long as their wooden counterparts.

Additionally, other factors to consider include how easy it is to install them, noise levels when in use, the shape of the seat itself, and whether or not a warranty is included with the purchase.

Winner: Plastic


At the end of the day, both wooden and plastic toilet seats can provide a comfortable experience for users. Although wooden toilet seats are more expensive and require more maintenance, they possess a timeless aesthetic that can completely transform any bathroom.

Plastic toilet seats are typically more affordable and don’t require as much upkeep, making them an excellent option for those who are looking for a more accessible and less expensive solution.

Ultimately, it’s essential to consider all factors, such as cost, durability, and maintenance, when deciding between wooden and plastic toilet seats. With both options equally attractive, the best way to decide is by weighing their pros and cons. By doing so, you can make a more informed decision explicitly tailored to your needs.

If you liked this article about wooden vs plastic toilet seats, consider checking out these other articles below —